The 1917 All-Star event at Fenway Park, a tribute to the late Tim Murnane, was more than just a baseball game. It was a spectacle that captured the essence of Boston's baseball culture and the spirit of the era. Scott D. Reich's book, "One Day In September," brings this event to life, detailing the game, the players, and the atmosphere. The event was a fundraiser for Murnane, a respected baseball writer and former player, who had passed away suddenly from a heart attack. The Red Sox, led by a crowd of 17,119, won 2-0, a result that was more significant than just a game score. The book also provides a glimpse into the life in Boston during World War I, a time of public rallies and civic engagement. The pregame activities, including a throwing contest, a bunt-and-run challenge, and a home run derby, were a testament to the era's excitement and the players' dedication. The special guests, such as boxing champion John L. Sullivan and humorist Will Rogers, added to the event's allure. However, the book also highlights the challenges of the era, such as the conflict between well-heeled Protestant Brahmins and working-class Catholics. The event was a natural reaction to Murnane's passing, a collective sense that they should do something for him and his family. The book serves as a reminder of the importance of baseball in Boston's history and the impact of individuals like Murnane, who kept the city connected to its team. In my opinion, Reich's book is a must-read for baseball enthusiasts and anyone interested in the history of Boston and its baseball culture. It provides a unique perspective on a significant event in baseball history, capturing the essence of the era and the people who made it memorable.
